← Back to Library
Home Service Expert

Delivering An Outstanding Customer Experience With HomeAdvisor with Craig Smith and Tommy Mello

πŸ“… December 25, 2019 ⏱️ 54:15 🎀 Craig Smith, Tommy Mello

Chapters

Click to jump to section

  • 0:00
    Intro: background checks and vetting vs. older mediums
  • 6:28
    Elite Service program for larger businesses
  • 9:45
    Narrowing focus to the home marketplace
  • 13:07
    Team values, culture, and tracking to invest confidently
  • 16:24
    Scaling from $15-30M toward $100M
  • 19:47
    Create raving fans - referrals are the best customers
  • 23:07
    Why competing on price alone fails
  • 26:28
    Filling idle time and evaluating return
  • 29:47
    Which media drives the highest return and close rate
  • 36:23
    He who can pay more per acquisition wins
  • 42:59
    Angie's List positioning and commitment to the home
  • 49:42
    Blockbuster-to-streaming analogy and the Home Service Millionaire book

Speakers

C
Craig Smith
Executive, HomeAdvisor / Angie's List
T
Tommy Mello
Host / Founder, A1 Garage Door Service

Key Takeaways

✦

HomeAdvisor added accountability that older advertising mediums lacked - comprehensive background checks and screening create a feedback loop that protects homeowners.

✦

For larger and medium-sized contractors, programs like Elite Service reward strong ratings and let quality businesses stand out in a competitive marketplace.

✦

Focus wins: narrowing to home-related categories rather than every service vertical let the marketplace become the best destination for anything related to the home.

✦

Track your numbers so you can confidently decide whether to invest more in a channel - measure the return before scaling spend.

✦

Referrals are the best customers, so create raving fans; competing purely on price is a trap small companies fall into.

✦

Fill idle time strategically - if the team is already paid and the schedule has gaps, a lower-return lead can still be worth booking to stay efficient.

✦

A core acquisition principle: 'he who can pay more per acquisition will always win' - but only if paired with great customer satisfaction that raises lifetime value.

✦

Markets shift like Blockbuster to Redbox to streaming - stay focused on the home and adapt to changing customer behavior or get left behind.

Want the full experience?

Join the Inner Circle for full access to every episode, AI-powered insights, personalized coaching, and a network of industry leaders.

Join Inner Circle β†’

Inner Circle Membership Portal © 2026 Power100. All rights reserved.

power100.io